Posted 22 November 2006 - 08:45 AM
US Market Timing
Advisors Sentiment
22 November 2006 By Mike Burke & John Gray
Overview
The ongoing record highs for the Dow Jones Industrials are starting to attract the bulls like flies to molasses. This week we saw the bulls up to 58.5%, up from 56.4% and 52.1% the prior two weeks. The bears were unchanged at 22.3% over the last week.
The remaining 19.2% are classified as correction, and that group declined from 21.3% a week ago. Those advisors are looking for shorter term weakness, but are longer term bullish.
Overall sentiment holds last week’s bearish shift. As we have seen quoted many places, the current levels don’t signal an imminent decline, but due warn that risk is increasing in a big way.
Historically, bulls are 55%-60% when indexes achieve record highs. Those extreme levels of optimism often prove negative as they reflect fully invested positions leaving little cash for additional purchases. At market tops we typically see the bears in the low 20%s.
The advisors have made a large move from mid-June, when the bulls and bears were even at 35.6%. That was a very positive signal that stocks were trading at a low risk area, and buying was in order. With the shift of recent weeks the sentiment has almost duplicated the extremes shown at the end of 2005, when there were 60.4% bulls, 20.8% bears and 18.8% correction. Other market indicators remain bullish, but at overbought levels where they have held for over seven weeks. There are again some new caution flags hoisted, but we again await confirming bearish signals.
The difference between the bulls and bears was 36.2%, from 34.1% and 26.1% the prior two weeks. This must also be considered as negative. Short term opportunities have been indicated after the spread between the bulls and bears contracted to 15% or lower, and then expanded. It was ‘0” mid-June and has been widening ever since.
Sentiment Charts
Bullish Themes
“The DJIA continued to record new all-time highs the last two weeks as did many of the Worlds’ major Stock Indices. Steady worldwide growth and historically low interest rates are fuelling the worldwide rally. Even the Global 300 Index hit new high, which includes the top stocks of the world. With Markets strong worldwide and with November-January the strongest period for stocks, we should enjoy some very profitable opportunities in coming weeks. This is especially true now the rally is broadening out.”
Tomorrow’s Stocks, POB 14111 Scottsdale, AZ 85267-1411
“Both the long-term NYSE Weekly Advance/Decline indicator and the short-term Daily Advance Decline line have been marching upward with the stock market. This confirmation of broad participation by the majority of stocks is one of the best arguments for continued progress. In fact, since this indicator is typically a leading indicator, we should witness a divergence/deterioration in the breadth prior to the stock market’s actual price peak. Thus far, so such divergence exists. The technical “green light” continues to shine brightly.”
The Primary Trend, First Financial Centre, 700 North Water St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Bearish Themes
“The stock market, as represented by the Dow Jones Average, continues to trade in record territory. Even the most minor of market dips, such as the one that developed the first week of November, brings in a new round of buying. When the momentum in this ever more speculative market legs begins to ebb, which is not a matter of if, but when, it will likely be a real donnybrook.
Part of the enthusiastic momentum in the market is due to the increased bullishness of the technologies. NASDAQ leader Microsoft moved to a four year high, and a bullish forecast by the second highest NASDAQ weight, Cisco Systems, sent that issue up sharply. There is nothing like hot-running technologies to get investors really excited.
That said, the current market advance is running on four months, which puts it at the long end of intermediate advances. The sizzling technologies have put the market into an afterburn. However, the longer the market goers with a correction to let off some steam, the more significant will be the correction when it does develop. Short-term risk may be low in a momentum-driven market, but longer-term risk is increasing.”
The Renaissance Report, 1540 Cambridge Ave, Flossmoor IL 60422
“With the ongoing inverted yield curve, widespread media assurances of a “soft landing” and some talking heads even suggesting the housing downturn has hit bottom….I’ll remain very skeptical. Resolution of the recently narrow 1390/1360 on the S&P will be instructive.”
Ian McAvity’s Deliberations, POB 182, Adelaide St Station Toronto, ONT M5C 2J1 Canada
Newsletter Extracts
Late in the Cycle
Universal Economics | Paul Macrae Montgomery, Editor | 753 Thimble Shoals Blvd, Suite B, Newport News VA 23606 | 757-597-9528
“Another possible sign that we are late in the current bull cycle is the explosion in Stock and Commodity Exchange IPOs and various other Exchange-related deals. On Friday the New York Mercantile Exchange went public at an IPO price of $59 a share, and rose immediately to $133 a share. At the latter price the company is priced at 20 times revenue, 33 times book and 72 times current earnings. Another fact of interest is that seats on the NYMEX were recently selling for $5 Million, the same price incidentally as a NYSE seat recently sold for. Typically high and/or rising seat prices occur during bull markets in the subject investment vehicle; and low and/or falling seat prices tend to occur during bear markets. This being the case, as long as NYSE and NYMEX seat prices keep rising, the bull markets in Stocks and in Commodities will probably be okay. However, we could be late in the "seat cycle" as well. It is virtually impossible for us to guess how high is too high for a seat on any exchange, however, we recall that for a period of time in the mid 1970s, several seats on the New York Stock Exchange sold for $50,000 or less. This amount was less than the contemporaneous price of a New York City Taxicab Medallion. We commented at the time, that if people were willing to pay more to drive a cab than to trade on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, then we were probably at some mammoth, long term low point in the stock market. Today by contrast, the price of a NYSE seat is more than 18 times the price of a NYC taxi medallion--viz., $5,000,000 versus $275,000. We do not know what "seat to medallion" ratio will constitute the ideal Sell signal for the stock market-but we are fairly sure that the current ratio of 18¼-to-1 is not a Buy signal.“ (20-Nov-06)
Canadian Income Trust Changes
Personal Finance | Neil George, Editor | 7600 Leesburg Pike, West Bldg #300, Falls Church, VA 22043 | www.pfnewsletter.com
“Never expect a politician to craft smart policy, especially when it comes to the markets. Cynical? You
decide.
Within days of praising income trusts as a boon for Canada’s markets and economy, the Tory-led
Canadian government, headed by Prime Minister Steve Harper and Finance Minister Jim Flaherty,
completely and abruptly changed course. The Dept of Finance announced a proposal for a new tax on
dividend distributions on many trusts. Although the initial fallout has been big, it doesn’t doom the entire
investment sector.
Even if you’re a newcomer to this market, the initial selloff has been big, but it hasn’t erased trusts’ overall
positive impact on our Portfolios for the past 12 months. That shows that despite the big pullback this
month, the broad market for trusts has generated a total return exceeding 10 percent. That’s on top of the
nearly 120 percent total return for the past five years, more than five times the S&P 500’s return.
It’s time to move past the shock, denial and anger with the Canadian politicos and assess the reality of
these tax changes.
Politicians may apologize and either delay or rescind the tax changes. Or they may give some
exemptions for specific trusts, such as the petrol trusts in Alberta, Canada.
However, we can’t hold and hope for what mayor may not come. We need to focus on the most-realistic
outcome. Pensioners on both sides of the border have been relying on trusts to bailout insolvent retirement
and pension funds.
And the trusts have helped bolster the Canadian economy, along with employment and investment flows
that generate
plenty of taxes. Still, politicians aren’t always the brightest bulbs in the room.
Changes
The pending regulation will impose a tax on trust distributions for dividends amounting to as much as 45.5
percent, bringing trusts in line with regular Canadian corporate tax rates. For Canadian investors, the net
impact is nil - it comes with an overall tax cut of 0.5 percent. Non-taxable investors, such as pension or
retirement funds, will see a tax rate of 31.5 percent, up from zero.
The pending regulations will impose a tax on trust distributions for dividends amounting to as much as 45 percent, bring trusts in line with regular Canadian corporate tax rates. For Canadian investors, the net impact is nil – it comes with an overall tax cut of 0.5 percent. Non-taxable investors, such as pension or retirement funds, will see a tax rate of 31.5 percent, up from zero.
In the US and other countries with tax treaties with Canada, the tax rate will go from 15 percent to 41.5 percent for taxable investment accounts, which is primarily recoverable against US income tax liabilities. And the tax rate is the same for non-taxable accounts in the US without any recovery mechanism.
The tax changes will be implemented for existing trusts in 2011 and immediately for any new trusts.
However, the tax law won't be levied against all segments of the trust market. There are four major segments of this market: petrol companies, business trusts, real estate investment trusts (REITs) and power generators and utilities.
The former two segments are subject to the new tax changes, while the latter will be unaffected by it. And some specific trusts that are structured to pay taxes-i.e., hybrid trusts, stapled shares, preferreds and convertibles-won't face changes either.
The Impact
Investors initially dumped about every trust in the market the morning after the announcement. But after the bombshell, traders and investors have begun to deal with the changes, resulting in some renewed buying and price recovery.
Dealing with the changes is what we've been doing with our current holdings inside the Growth and Income Portfolios. We're reviewing each trust segment and our individual trusts in the Canadian market.
The key to remember is that, even with the shake-up in this market, many of the trust continue to justify our investment. Just because we’ve been hit with the sudden tax changes doesn’t alter the fact that the structure of the trusts favors shareholders more so than most other security structures in and outside Canada and the US.
By paying the bulk of their profits from their solid business to shareholders, rather than to management or stockpiling, many trusts have and continue to generate solid returns and dividends for us.” (22-Nov-06)