What would drive IYB Don nuts is if the "important" Bradley turn dates at the end of July are also an "important" market top.

You Bradley guys are always lots of fun, but I'm still waiting for someone, anyone, to post a trade here in real time based on a Bradley call. At "the end of July" the SPX had dropped 53 points over the preceding week, DJ -580 points, so it's hard for me to see how you call that a "market top". If anything, from the "rules" I've gotten Bradley folks to lay out here, you would have had to call July 29 a "bottom" when you were operating in real time, because
the trend into that time was sharply down, so a "turn date" implied that it would "turn up".

Last time I looked up "turn" that's how Webster 'splained it anyhow.
Bradley is an amusing excercize, in my humble opinion, in going back after the fact and curve fitting an interpretation. I got very good at that with Studley as you may recall. One thing that I realized when I did the Studley stuff, btw, was that any day of the century contains reversals on key stocks or indices, so that when you asign meaning *after the fact*, you can find all kinds of "perfect fits".
Of course I realize that you called {or
mused about because you likely allowed for the possabilty that it could actually be a bottom, or even a "miss"} an "important market top"
before the fact when you originally posed that comment, RD, but the fact remains that the end of July just flat wasn't a top, since markets dropped 580 points in the last five days of July
before that date....and again, the interpretive rules would have called, then, for that to be a
bottom, not a top.
Now mind you - I am not suggesting that July 29 was not a GREAT time to short...In fact I got an SSSS and shorted Aug 2, and have spectacular profits as a result.... an open position of over 70 points on the ES's. I'm just saying that Bradley - in real time - flat out didn't tell anyone to go short there. If it had, all anyone would have had to do then - in real time on July 29 - was post here something like....
"I'm SHORTING here based on Bradley." Period. I've been asking for that for about 8 years now.
All that being said -- you are still my favorite poster here, RD. In fact
YOU have been very right on these markets. But Dr. Bradley didn't call nuttin - 'cept after the fact, using the usual data fitting.

Okay, there's my rant. Just spouting off.

Very best regards, D
http://stockcharts.com/c-sc/sc?s=$SPX&p=D&yr=1&mn=7&dy=0&i=p23824210672&a=181755090&r=866.png
Edited by IYB, 06 August 2011 - 02:54 PM.