9 replies to this topic

[Rogerdodger]

It looks like a low.
Look at the 89ma (green) has turned up from the lowest low of the month.
http://stockcharts.com/c-sc/sc?s=$TICK&p=5&yr=0&mn=1&dy=0&i=p14999560505&a=111513787&r=3726.png

[A-ha]

Something is wrong with that chart or it is not net tick. Tick hit -1402 yesterday at 1:46 ET

There was another tick reading lower than -1400 on 6/7/7 which had caused 17 additional spx points plunge.

I think this will do worse.


following 60 day 1 minute tick

Edited by xD&Cox, 11 July 2007 - 12:01 PM.

[zedor]

The tick indicator in my view is in a new ball game as of last Friday July 6 when the uptick rule was abolished. Prior to that artificial tick blasts were necessary to be able to short stocks -- that no longer applies. So any indicator based on the tick and or cummulative tick needs to be calibrated to the new reality of July 6 2007.

[NAV]

XD, I don't trust the Stockcharts TICK either. My charts showed a intraday low TICK of -1331 (not quite -1400 that your chart shows). I trust mine

[A-ha]

-1331? Thats a new one... Looks like everybody got something different. I wonder why....

[NAV]

-1331? Thats a new one...
Looks like everybody got something different. I wonder why....

This is not the first time i have seen such a discrepany in TICK from different data providers. IB , Tradestation, Prophet.net all gives different values for me. I don't know whom to trust. They are all close though. But stockcharts is way off...

Edited by NAV, 11 July 2007 - 12:50 PM.

[Darris]

From what I have read, each service or vendor provides the data as a snap shot in time with intervals from each second up to a data point every 6 seconds. For IB users, have any of you ever been able to subscribe or get the TICK and TRIN on TWS, and if so, what is the symbol? Thanks in advance.

[kaiser soze]

On IB the symbols are TRIN-NYSE and TICK-NYSE for NYSE indicators. Also TRIN-NASD and TICK-NASD for the Naz.

[Darris]

kaiser soze, Thanks for that info. Always nice to have several sources of this data.

[Rogerdodger]

Guess I didn't make clear what I see. Look at the green ma. It turned up. That's all. Sometimes you see so many trees you miss the forest.